Posts Tagged ‘newspapers’

5 Things to Watch–and Act On

Monday, December 14th, 2009

We have issued our Top 5 recommendations for local online advertising in 2010. They’re pretty straightforward:  Identify and copy the fastest growers, start partnering with other companies, offer “promotions” services to advertisers, monitor but be cautious about mobile, and dive into video advertising. But I thought I’d also offers some predictions for 2010 that might startle you.

First, I’m excited to announce that we have a new list of speakers we’ll be announcing this week for our Feb. 8-9 conference in New York. In the spirit of identifying and copying the fastest-growing local online advertising companies, we’ve gone to the trouble of identifying them for you — and getting their top executives to stand up at our conference and tell you why they’ve become the new darlings of Main Street.  We’ve also secured speakers from companies like Fisher Broadcasting, which has launched 43 hyperlocal sites in Seattle that are fast becoming profitable, as well as leading revenue producers in email, video, promotions and paid search.  Wait ’til you see the final agenda.

OK, on to the startling things.  I believe that 2010 will see a clear divide between the local media companies that are crossing the gorge and those being left behind.  Positive growth in Internet revenues will be the delineator.  Those who continue to see declines will clearly have tied their Internet operations too closely to their legacy media companies or will have formulated products that don’t resonate with Main Street advertisers.  Other predictions:

Largest Local Online Advertising Companies, 2009

Largest Local Online Advertising Companies, 2009

1.  Newspapers rebound.  Look for a 2-4% increase in newspaper ad revenues next year.  Smaller papers might fare better.  Those who make the digital transition will see up to 20% of their total ad revenues coming from the Internet next year.  The Yahoo-newspaper partnerships will generate $200 million to $300 million in geo-targeted banner sales.

2.  Local Internet advertising grows 5-9% next year, making it harder than ever for many companies to ride whatever tide is left.

3.  Mobile advertising skyrockets (on a small base), but local ad buys remain short-term and experimental.

4.  Cable companies dive deeper into local Internet sales.  Look for acquisitions and partnerships like we saw with the Yellow Pages in the early to mid-1990s.

5.  Yellow Pages continue a precipitous decline, high single digits but perhaps double digits for some.  Meanwhile, their Internet revenues will grow to comprise one-fifth of ad revenues.

Predictions are no more than educated guesses, so I really didn’t want to spend too much time on speculation.  The recommendations are key to what I think you should be watching.  The largest local online advertising companies are interesting to observe, but the fastest-growing ones above $25 million in revenue are the ones worth studying — and copying.

I hope you can make it to our conference.  We’re going to spend a lot of time dissecting these companies and learning why local advertisers have become so enamored of what they’re offering.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Reddit
  • Twitter

The Lady in the Sweat Suit

Saturday, November 7th, 2009

I was in a 7-Eleven last week and watched a middle-aged woman in a sweat suit pay $1.50 for the Sunday newspaper, then walk outside and dump half of it in the trashcan. Care to guess what part she dumped?

Like 37% of newspaper readers (according to Scarborough Research), she’s interested in the advertising. Her $1.50 was likely to have bought her at least $5 in coupons that she’ll redeem at the grocery store, Rite Aid or Wal-Mart. Smart purchase.

While most of the newspaper industry frets over giving away its precious news content, its most vulnerable franchise is produced by the advertising department. Newspapers should thank their lucky stars that the woman in the sweat suit did what she did. She could have stayed at home and gone to SalesCircular.com or one of the many other sites that would have given her the same thing. If she were in Long Island, she might get her coupons from www.yourli.com, an incredibly useful and popular site run by a group of radio stations. If she were in Bakersfield, Calif., she might go to www.shopkern.com, a shopping and coupon site run by KERO-TV.

I hope publishers learn soon that their most important content isn’t its local news.  It’s advertising. The issue was underscored last week when the president of the Newspaper Association of America sent a e-mail warning that J.C. Penney’s and Sears were threatening to pull their circulars because of lower circulation and the industry’s inability to reach younger demos. Circulars, he said, account for half of all newspaper retail advertising.

Local-allocation

I wouldn’t count newspapers out. Despite layoffs, bankruptcies circulation scandals and thinning classified sections, they are still king when it comes to local advertising. The crown is tarnished, but at the end of the day newspapers still control the largest slice of the $143 billion local ad pie, 26%. The next-closest share: Interactive at 14%. Then broadcast TV at 12%, then Direct Mail at 11%. Advertisers know about the lady in the sweat suit, and they’re eager to meet her on Saturdays and Sundays when she’s got her wallet and credit cards ready.  Newspapers remain the No. 1 source for coupons, representing 50% of all coupon sources.  The Internet represents 11%, but is certainly growing.

Newspapers are vulnerable, but their managers aren’t dumb. Gannett owns ShopLocal.com, an Internet distribution mechanism for its print circulars now plugged into all its newspaper and TV sites. The Suburban Newspapers of America this fall launched www.zip2save.com and is signing up smaller newspapers across the country. It’s modeled after www.flyerland.ca, a highly successful site created by Metroland Newspapers in Canada.

The debate over charging for news content is silly. Rupert Murdoch may be carrying the battle flag, but the legions of publishers following him over the hill appear to be heading into the sunset.  Charging for online access may slow the erosion in print circulation, but it’s never going to lead the industry to riches. Understanding the behavior of the lady in the sweat suit will.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Reddit
  • Twitter

The rumors of newspapers’ death

Thursday, August 6th, 2009

You might think it takes a great deal of chutzpah to say that newspapers will see a mild rebound over the next several years. But all it really takes is a close examination of the trends and cycles, and a deep understanding of the history of electronic media.

So here are our latest projections: Newspapers will be down this year, then they’ll start going back up. We expect a 2.4% rebound in newspaper advertising in 2010, and continued single-digit increases over the next several years. By 2014, newspaper ad revenues will be up about 8.7% over 2009 levels. While national newspaper advertising will do just fine, we foresee the greatest growth in local print – going from $8.9 billion this year to $10.1 billion, a 13.4% increase.

True, it all equates to more of a dead-cat bounce than anything else. And even at 2014 levels of just under $30 billion, newspaper advertising won’t be anything near the $55 billion we saw earlier this decade. Nor will it ever return to that level.

The fact is, newspapers reached their peak 91 years ago as two publishers battled over the presidency. On Nov. 2, 1920, in the first-ever radio news broadcast, KDKA delivered the results: Warren Harding beat James Cox. Electronic media was born, as was the business of writing obituaries for the newspaper industry.

The long history of electronic media has proven that there’s never a one-for-one exchange. People don’t go to the Web to “read a newspaper,” much the way they don’t turn on the TV set to watch “radio with pictures.” Radio forced newspapers in the 1920s to become more local. TV’s expansion into evening news in the 1960s forced afternoon newspapers out of business. The Internet sucked the life out of newspapers’ classified advertising and as the number of pages shrank, forced newspapers to find ways to become more interesting, more relative to their audiences.

The latest mediamorphosis of newspapers is almost complete. This once-fat, gray caterpillar that we knew as the “major daily newspaper” is turning into a smaller, more delicate, colorful local magazine, with fair prospects for growth. The smaller newspapers are firmly entrenched in their niche of providing rich local content that people seem to prefer in print – rather than screen – format. Our local newspaper, the Virginia Gazette in Williamsburg, is actually growing circulation and is thick with advertising supplements.

We may be dead wrong. The entire industry might die, and scores of papers might go belly-up over the next year. I’d like you to mark your calendar for today’s date, 2010, and see if that’s the case, or if we wound up being right.

I welcome your comments and debate on this issue.

Download the memo.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Reddit
  • Twitter

Michael Jackson and the media moonwalk

Friday, June 26th, 2009

Michael Jackson’s untimely demise proved that, despite the ubiquity of the Internet, traditional media still has an enormous share of people’s attention. While many turned to the Internet for their initial bit of information, eyeballs and ears were inextricably drawn to other media Thursday night and Friday morning. They were glued to the television set in the evening, picking up the newspaper in the morning, and listening to the radio on the way to work. The same thing happened in the aftermath of the presidential election. Everyone was in front of a TV in the evening, and newsstands were sold out the next morning.

Is this just a media moonwalk, like Michael Jackson appearing to move forward while actually moving backward?

The Internet is a fantastic medium for tipping people off to what’s happening, and in many cases for “going deep” on a subject and learning a lot more detail on hard-to-find bits of information. Its strength as a medium is undeniably powerful. But newspapers also have their own undeniable benefits, as do billboards, broadcast TV, radio, and the Yellow Pages.

I’m sorry for the passing of the King of Pop. Say what you will about his strange behavior, but he was indeed one of the most talented performers of the century and drove a lot of media time – even in death.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Reddit
  • Twitter